[PDB Tech] allow empty IP field or not?

[Joe Provo]

On Wed, Dec 28, 2016 at 12:55:22AM +0100, Arnold Nipper wrote:
> On 25.12.2016 19:26, Joe Provo wrote:
> > [this time form the correct address...]
> > 
> > On Sun, Dec 25, 2016 at 03:15:39PM +0100, Sascha Pollok wrote:
> >> Hi Job, et al,
> >>
> >> Let's please keep it required. Many people rely on PDB information to 
> >> automate peering configurations. It does not happen often that we need to 
> >> configure peering sessions that require manual input and when it happens, 
> >> it is actually annoying. Making IP addresses optional will make more ASes 
> >> not document them either of lazyness or weird security reasons. If someone 
> >> thinks not disclosing them gives extra security they do have a problem 
> >> anyway. It's easy to find out peering LAN IPs if someone wants to do 
> >> something ugly.
> >>
> >> Please keep them required.
> > 
> > Yes.
> > 
> > If the [not uncommon] case of signaling intent-to-be-there is needed,
> > that should be simply a separate flag not an overloading of the address
> > field.
> > 
> 
> Isn't there always an overloading one way or the other? Given we do yaf
> (yet another flag) which says intent-to-be-there. But what is the
> meaning of this flag when an address is added? I know the address but
> I'm not yet ready? Or still the original meaning.

YAF in the abscensce of an allocation helps planners, espcaeccialy in
companies where things take too long. Obvs it had no meaning once there 
are both AFs in place. There would be an argument to be made for one AF 
and YAF set to indicate one is planning to add the other AF.
 
> Same is for privacy. If a network doesn't want to disclose its IP there
> may be reasons for it. Otherwise it wouldn't do so.

The "reason" is weird or useless at best IME.

> Imho all we need is a common understanding what something means. Does it
> really hurt if we allow an empty IP address?  Does it break any automation?

yes. folks have to trap for that case, and it is indeterminate:
intentional? user error? IX error? etc


-- 
Posted from my personal account - see X-Disclaimer header.
Joe Provo / Gweep / Earthling